%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>
endobj
2 0 obj
<>stream
Emily C. Parke, Brett Calcott, Maureen A. O’Malley
A cautionary note for claims about the microbiome’s impact on the “self”
www.ploscompbiol.org
www.ploscompbiol.org
endstream
endobj
3 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 10 0 R/Contents 11 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
10 0 obj
[12 0 R 13 0 R 14 0 R 15 0 R 16 0 R]
endobj
12 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpbio.2006654.ref005)>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpbio.2006654.ref007)>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpbio.2006654.ref008)>>
endobj
15 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/Dest(Rpbio.2006654.ref009)>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/Border[0 0 0]/A 17 0 R>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
[18 0 R 19 0 R 20 0 R 21 0 R 22 0 R 23 0 R 24 0 R]
endobj
18 0 obj
<>stream
q
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
241.285 576.3402 m
246.0472 576.3402 l
h
f*
251.2063 576.3402 m
255.9685 576.3402 l
h
f*
203.4142 329.1024 m
208.1764 329.1024 l
h
f*
213.3354 329.1024 m
218.0976 329.1024 l
h
f*
0 g
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 707.4141 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(When)Tj
2.6815 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(authors)Tj
3.2428 0 Td
(argue)Tj
2.4435 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(microbiomes)Tj
5.4935 0 Td
(co-constitute)Tj
6.2362 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9389 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(are,)Tj
1.6781 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(most)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(probably)Tj
-34.0495 -1.3039 Td
(mean)Tj
2.4434 0 Td
(host)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
5.1307 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(physiologically)Tj
6.1455 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(developmentally)Tj
6.7918 0 Td
(united,)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(hosts)Tj
-33.8851 -1.2982 Td
(such)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(humans)Tj
3.4412 0 Td
(would)Tj
2.7099 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(function)Tj
3.6283 0 Td
(without)Tj
3.3279 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.1089 0 Td
(microbes.)Tj
4.1272 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(agree)Tj
2.3357 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7802 0 Td
(causal)Tj
2.6419 0 Td
(relationships)Tj
-32.3601 -1.2983 Td
(between)Tj
3.5262 0 Td
(individual)Tj
4.2803 0 Td
(microbes)Tj
3.8948 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(small)Tj
2.3188 0 Td
(groups)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(microbes)Tj
3.8948 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4626 0 Td
(host)Tj
1.9106 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(very)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(likely)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(impact)Tj
-34.8375 -1.2983 Td
(how)Tj
1.9388 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(host)Tj
1.9162 0 Td
(survives)Tj
3.4412 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(thrives)Tj
2.9197 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(daily)Tj
2.1486 0 Td
(life.)Tj
1.6725 0 Td
(But)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(suggesting)Tj
4.3994 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(whole)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
5.1364 0 Td
(is)Tj
-35.2911 -1.3039 Td
(causal)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(problematic)Tj
5.0343 0 Td
(\(e.g.,)Tj
2.126 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.8595 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
5.1363 0 Td
(also)Tj
1.7689 0 Td
(plays)Tj
2.2336 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(central)Tj
2.965 0 Td
(role)Tj
1.7688 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(three)Tj
2.2621 0 Td
(processes)Tj
3.9685 0 Td
(that)Tj
-35.773 -1.2982 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(traditionally)Tj
5.1193 0 Td
(been)Tj
2.126 0 Td
(said)Tj
1.8085 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(define)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(self\).)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(simply)Tj
2.8856 0 Td
(don't)Tj
2.3188 0 Td
(know)Tj
2.4547 0 Td
(what)Tj
2.1657 0 Td
(most)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(of)Tj
-35.5178 -1.2983 Td
(our)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(microbes)Tj
3.8947 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4457 0 Td
(doing,)Tj
2.7553 0 Td
(how)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(much)Tj
2.5115 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9218 0 Td
(contribute,)Tj
4.6148 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7235 0 Td
(whether)Tj
3.4695 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.1033 0 Td
(effects)Tj
2.7213 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(indispensable)Tj
-32.1616 -1.3039 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(biology.)Tj
3.3959 0 Td
(This)Tj
1.9899 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(merely)Tj
2.9593 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(matter)Tj
2.8629 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(missing)Tj
3.3109 0 Td
(knowledge.)Tj
4.7678 0 Td
(Many)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
5.1307 0 Td
(par-)Tj
-35.1607 -1.2983 Td
(ticipants)Tj
3.6339 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4514 0 Td
(known)Tj
3.0047 0 Td
(empirically)Tj
4.6885 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(theoretically)Tj
5.142 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(transient,)Tj
3.9968 0 Td
(opportunistic,)Tj
5.8564 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0941 0 Td
(even)Tj
2.075 0 Td
(inac-)Tj
-34.8489 -1.2983 Td
(tive)Tj
1.661 0 Td
(\(e.g.,)Tj
2.126 0 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(5)Tj
0 g
()Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(7)Tj
0 g
(]\).)Tj
2.9367 0 Td
(They)Tj
2.2337 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(thus)Tj
1.9332 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(much)Tj
2.5172 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.4696 0 Td
(constituting)Tj
5.4254 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(many)Tj
2.4775 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(organismal)Tj
-30.6083 -1.3039 Td
(aspects)Tj
3.0387 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(environment,)Tj
5.6523 0 Td
(such)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(ticks)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(fleas.)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
11.9999 0 0 11.9999 200.0125 529.1716 cm
BT
/F2 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0033 Tc
0 0 Td
(Humanistic)Tj
5.5653 0 Td
(concepts)Tj
4.578 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.1575 0 Td
(self)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 512.2204 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(Although)Tj
4.0024 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(authors)Tj
3.2485 0 Td
(acknowledge)Tj
5.3971 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(sciences)Tj
3.4526 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(addressed)Tj
4.1782 0 Td
(multiple)Tj
3.566 0 Td
(under-)Tj
-33.698 -1.3039 Td
(standings)Tj
4.0308 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(self,)Tj
1.7631 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(make)Tj
2.3981 0 Td
(no)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(attempt)Tj
3.3052 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(identify)Tj
3.2938 0 Td
(them.)Tj
2.5172 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.61 0 Td
(find)Tj
1.8482 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(three)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(their)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(essay.)Tj
-34.35 -1.2982 Td
(At)Tj
1.2018 0 Td
(times,)Tj
2.6136 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(authors)Tj
3.2485 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(mind)Tj
2.3811 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(uniqueness)Tj
4.7111 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(species)Tj
2.9934 0 Td
(\(what)Tj
2.897 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.788 0 Td
(means)Tj
2.8063 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
-36.2718 -1.2983 Td
(human,)Tj
3.6963 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(distinctive)Tj
4.7508 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(traits)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(set)Tj
1.3039 0 Td
(us)Tj
1.1056 0 Td
(apart)Tj
2.2733 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2054 0 Td
(all)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(animals\).)Tj
4.286 0 Td
(At)Tj
1.2018 0 Td
(other)Tj
2.3471 0 Td
(times,)Tj
-33.7717 -1.3039 Td
(they)Tj
1.9218 0 Td
(focus)Tj
2.3244 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2699 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(individual)Tj
4.2859 0 Td
(first-person)Tj
4.8813 0 Td
(experience)Tj
4.5013 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(being)Tj
2.4265 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(self)Tj
1.5363 0 Td
(\(self-awareness,)Tj
6.8825 0 Td
(personality)Tj
-33.1651 -1.2983 Td
(traits,)Tj
2.4717 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7348 0 Td
(emotional)Tj
4.269 0 Td
(state,)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(traits)Tj
2.6419 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(consider)Tj
3.651 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0205 0 Td
(define)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(sense)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(self\).)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(At)Tj
1.2019 0 Td
(still)Tj
1.6384 0 Td
(other)Tj
-34.5654 -1.2982 Td
(times,)Tj
2.6135 0 Td
(they)Tj
1.9219 0 Td
(seem)Tj
2.2506 0 Td
(concerned)Tj
4.4164 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(agency)Tj
2.9707 0 Td
(or)Tj
1.0998 0 Td
(free)Tj
1.7235 0 Td
(will)Tj
1.6667 0 Td
(\(our)Tj
2.3584 0 Td
(resident)Tj
3.4413 0 Td
(microbes)Tj
3.9004 0 Td
(orchestrate)Tj
4.6601 0 Td
(the)Tj
-35.0189 -1.304 Td
(adaptive)Tj
3.5773 0 Td
(immune)Tj
3.6226 0 Td
(system)Tj
2.9423 0 Td
([and])Tj
2.4095 0 Td
(influence)Tj
3.9174 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(brain\).)Tj
-16.7413 -1.2982 Td
(Asking)Tj
3.0444 0 Td
(what)Tj
2.1656 0 Td
(it)Tj
0.7824 0 Td
(means)Tj
2.8062 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0375 0 Td
(any)Tj
1.6554 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(those)Tj
2.3358 0 Td
(three)Tj
2.2677 0 Td
(senses)Tj
2.6985 0 Td
(abstracts)Tj
3.7077 0 Td
(away)Tj
2.2281 0 Td
(from)Tj
2.2053 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(spe-)Tj
-35.8693 -1.2983 Td
(cifics)Tj
2.2506 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(biological)Tj
4.0933 0 Td
(constitution.)Tj
5.295 0 Td
(These)Tj
2.5682 0 Td
(questions)Tj
4.0195 0 Td
(focus)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(instead)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(who)Tj
1.9388 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3267 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(as)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(self-cog-)Tj
-33.2785 -1.2983 Td
(nizing)Tj
2.7269 0 Td
(individuals,)Tj
4.8755 0 Td
(with)Tj
1.9956 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(rich)Tj
1.8085 0 Td
(diversity)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(mental,)Tj
3.2201 0 Td
(emotional,)Tj
4.4958 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(cultural)Tj
3.2938 0 Td
(resources.)Tj
-30.4325 -1.3039 Td
(Questions)Tj
4.2576 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4944 0 Td
(biological)Tj
4.0932 0 Td
(constitution)Tj
5.0684 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(still)Tj
1.6384 0 Td
(relevant:)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(material)Tj
3.5149 0 Td
(bases)Tj
2.3074 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(mind)Tj
2.3811 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(con-)Tj
-35.0643 -1.2982 Td
(sciousness)Tj
4.3596 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(deep)Tj
2.109 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(interesting)Tj
4.4957 0 Td
(questions.)Tj
4.2463 0 Td
(But)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(connections)Tj
5.0796 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4457 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(straightforward.)Tj
-30.3702 -1.2983 Td
(Consider)Tj
3.8891 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(burgeoning)Tj
4.8529 0 Td
(work)Tj
2.279 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(cognitive)Tj
3.8778 0 Td
(science)Tj
3.0897 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7292 0 Td
(philosophy)Tj
4.6544 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.8595 0 Td
(extended)Tj
3.8608 0 Td
(mind)Tj
-33.8681 -1.3039 Td
([)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(8)Tj
0 g
()Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
(9)Tj
0 g
(].)Tj
2.5908 0 Td
(On)Tj
1.5194 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(accounts,)Tj
3.9684 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6577 0 Td
(smartphone)Tj
5.0286 0 Td
(can)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(constitute)Tj
4.1782 0 Td
(part)Tj
1.8369 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6271 0 Td
(mind,)Tj
2.6078 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(suggests)Tj
3.4809 0 Td
(that)Tj
-35.0359 -1.2983 Td
(\(counter)Tj
3.6566 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(Rees)Tj
2.0522 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(colleagues')Tj
4.4901 0 Td
(claims)Tj
2.7723 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4944 0 Td
(biological)Tj
4.0932 0 Td
(concepts)Tj
3.7191 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(self\))Tj
1.8822 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(internal)Tj
3.3562 0 Td
(composi-)Tj
-33.7547 -1.2982 Td
(tion)Tj
1.8425 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(our)Tj
1.6214 0 Td
(bodies)Tj
2.8176 0 Td
(is)Tj
0.8447 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(main)Tj
2.2904 0 Td
(criterion)Tj
3.6963 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(constituting)Tj
5.0343 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(least)Tj
1.9842 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(sense)Tj
2.3414 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(humanistic)Tj
4.6941 0 Td
(or)Tj
-36.2718 -1.304 Td
(psychological)Tj
5.6012 0 Td
(selfhood.)Tj
-4.405 -1.2982 Td
(Crucially,)Tj
4.0818 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(various)Tj
3.1464 0 Td
(concepts)Tj
3.719 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9525 0 Td
(play)Tj
1.8708 0 Td
(here)Tj
1.9673 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(competing)Tj
4.49 0 Td
(attempts)Tj
3.6737 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(define)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(some)Tj
2.3301 0 Td
(uni-)Tj
-35.6426 -1.2983 Td
(tary)Tj
1.7744 0 Td
(concept)Tj
3.3619 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.8652 0 Td
(individual)Tj
4.2859 0 Td
(human)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(self,)Tj
2.1544 0 Td
(nor)Tj
1.6497 0 Td
(do)Tj
1.2529 0 Td
(claims)Tj
2.7723 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(one)Tj
1.7007 0 Td
(concept)Tj
3.3619 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(self)Tj
1.5364 0 Td
(automati-)Tj
-33.3182 -1.2983 Td
(cally)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(apply)Tj
2.3867 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0262 0 Td
(another.)Tj
3.5546 0 Td
(Each)Tj
2.177 0 Td
(concept)Tj
3.3619 0 Td
(plays)Tj
2.2336 0 Td
(importantly)Tj
4.9833 0 Td
(different)Tj
3.6567 0 Td
(roles)Tj
2.126 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7801 0 Td
(span)Tj
2.0806 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(natural)Tj
3.0784 0 Td
(and)Tj
-35.9374 -1.3039 Td
(social)Tj
2.4547 0 Td
(sciences)Tj
3.4526 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(humanities.)Tj
4.921 0 Td
(For)Tj
1.627 0 Td
(instance,)Tj
3.7531 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(might)Tj
2.5965 0 Td
(establish)Tj
3.6453 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(identity)Tj
4.0932 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(criminal)Tj
-32.7342 -1.2982 Td
(through)Tj
3.4412 0 Td
(genetic)Tj
3.0727 0 Td
(material)Tj
3.515 0 Td
(left)Tj
1.474 0 Td
(at)Tj
0.9524 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(scene)Tj
2.4038 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(then)Tj
2.0183 0 Td
(excuse)Tj
2.846 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(crime)Tj
2.5228 0 Td
(on)Tj
1.2756 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(basis)Tj
2.1543 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(crimi-)Tj
-34.2933 -1.2983 Td
(nal's)Tj
2.0239 0 Td
(state)Tj
2.0352 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(mind)Tj
2.3811 0 Td
(during)Tj
2.931 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(crime)Tj
2.5228 0 Td
(\(she)Tj
1.8765 0 Td
(was)Tj
1.6951 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5761 0 Td
(herself\).)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
11.9999 0 0 11.9999 200.0125 178.0157 cm
BT
/F2 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.0033 Tc
0 0 Td
(Connecting)Tj
5.6929 0 Td
(science,)Tj
4.1245 0 Td
(humanities,)Tj
5.7402 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.9937 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.7055 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
10 0 0 10 200.0125 161.0078 cm
BT
/F5 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.004 Tc
0 0 Td
(In)Tj
1.1055 0 Td
(pointing)Tj
3.6396 0 Td
(out)Tj
1.5534 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(various)Tj
3.1465 0 Td
(biological,)Tj
4.3143 0 Td
(humanistic,)Tj
4.9209 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(psychological)Tj
5.6012 0 Td
(senses)Tj
2.6986 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(which)Tj
2.6532 0 Td
(Rees)Tj
2.0466 0 Td
(and)Tj
-35.909 -1.2982 Td
(colleagues)Tj
4.2746 0 Td
(seem)Tj
2.2507 0 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1509 0 Td
(talking)Tj
2.9706 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(self,)Tj
2.5512 0 Td
(we)Tj
1.3266 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4513 0 Td
(not)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(advocating)Tj
4.5808 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.6519 0 Td
(rigid)Tj
2.1203 0 Td
(divide)Tj
2.6873 0 Td
(between)Tj
3.5319 0 Td
(science)Tj
-34.6391 -1.3039 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(humanities.)Tj
4.9209 0 Td
(We)Tj
1.6101 0 Td
(are)Tj
1.4456 0 Td
(challenging)Tj
4.8189 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(authors')Tj
3.4639 0 Td
(suggestion)Tj
4.4447 0 Td
(that)Tj
1.7745 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4683 0 Td
(humanities)Tj
4.6999 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(arts)Tj
1.6838 0 Td
(need)Tj
-35.2571 -1.2983 Td
(to)Tj
1.0261 0 Td
(be)Tj
1.1508 0 Td
(fundamentally)Tj
6.0151 0 Td
(overhauled)Tj
4.6658 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(light)Tj
2.024 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0147 0 Td
(microbiome)Tj
5.1364 0 Td
(research)Tj
3.5546 0 Td
(\(their)Tj
2.4491 0 Td
(call)Tj
1.5704 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(a)Tj
0.652 0 Td
(whole)Tj
3.0047 0 Td
(new)Tj
-34.6788 -1.2983 Td
(configuration)Tj
5.6692 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(research)Tj
3.9515 0 Td
(resulting)Tj
3.7303 0 Td
(in)Tj
1.0318 0 Td
(microbial)Tj
4.4561 0 Td
(humanities\).)Tj
5.6522 0 Td
(Throughout)Tj
5.091 0 Td
(the)Tj
1.4684 0 Td
(history)Tj
3.0103 0 Td
(of)Tj
1.0148 0 Td
(sci-)Tj
-36.0904 -1.3039 Td
(ence,)Tj
2.262 0 Td
(Western)Tj
3.6113 0 Td
(society)Tj
2.9594 0 Td
(has)Tj
1.542 0 Td
(gained)Tj
2.8856 0 Td
(numerous)Tj
4.303 0 Td
(transformative)Tj
6.1001 0 Td
(insights)Tj
3.3165 0 Td
(about)Tj
2.4945 0 Td
(what)Tj
2.16 0 Td
(constitutes)Tj
4.5354 0 Td
(our)Tj
-36.1698 -1.2982 Td
(bodies)Tj
2.8119 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(brains.)Tj
2.9367 0 Td
(While)Tj
2.6475 0 Td
(hugely)Tj
2.8687 0 Td
(important)Tj
4.2803 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3833 0 Td
(both)Tj
2.0636 0 Td
(science)Tj
3.0897 0 Td
(and)Tj
1.7291 0 Td
(society,)Tj
3.1805 0 Td
(these)Tj
2.2564 0 Td
(insights)Tj
3.3165 0 Td
(have)Tj
2.0579 0 Td
(an)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
576 737.1 m
36 737.1 l
36 737.6 l
576 737.6 l
f*
36 741.2598 129.8268 23.6976 re
W* n
q
129.7701 0 0 23.6409 36 741.3165 cm
q
/I0 Do
Q
Q
Q
q
0 0 612 792 re
W* n
1 j
1 J
0 w
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 438.2929 745.7952 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(A)Tj
0.8787 0 Td
(cautionar)Tj
4.0323 0 Td
(y)Tj
0.7158 0 Td
(note)Tj
2.1331 0 Td
(for)Tj
1.3677 0 Td
(microbiom)Tj
4.5284 0 Td
(e)Tj
0.7653 0 Td
(claims)Tj
ET
Q
q
1 j
1 J
0 w
36 48.0002 m
576 48.0002 l
576 47.5002 l
36 47.5002 l
f*
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
90.1417 34.9228 m
243.8362 34.9228 l
h
f*
0 g
7.9999 0 0 7.9999 36 36 cm
BT
/F0 1 Tf
1 TL
-0.005 Tc
0 0 Td
(PLOS)Tj
2.8559 0 Td
(Biology)Tj
3.437 0 Td
(|)Tj
0.83 0.64 0.02 0 k
0.4748 0 Td
(https://doi.or)Tj
5.4142 0 Td
(g/10.137)Tj
3.8198 0 Td
(1/journal.pb)Tj
5.1236 0 Td
(io.2006654)Tj
0 g
5.8536 0 Td
(Septemb)Tj
3.9402 0 Td
(er)Tj
1.0913 0 Td
(12,)Tj
1.5875 0 Td
(2018)Tj
32.0884 0 Td
(2)Tj
0.7654 0 Td
(/)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<>stream
endstream
endobj
24 0 obj
<>stream
BT
66.9477 0 Td
(4)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<>/XObject<>>>/CropBox[0 0 612 792]/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 9 0 R/Annots 28 0 R/Contents 29 0 R/TrimBox[0 0 612 792]>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<>
endobj
30 0 obj
<>
endobj
33 0 obj
<>stream
MinionPro-It 9 `ab]+
W W Y ' - 3 > H N T Z ` j q t { +2=CIU[cnz~
"(.9CIOU[elov|&-8>DPV^iuy &+/49@DGLPU[]_ahjmru|
&-4;BIPW^elsz
")07>ELSZahov} %,3:AHOV]dkry#/;JTey ! ( / 6 = D K R Y ` g n u |
$
+
2
9
@
G
N
U
\
c
j
q
x
'.5<CJQX_fmt{ #*18?FMT[bkry
"
)
0
7
>
E
J
O
W
d
q
v
$+29@GNU\cjqx '.5<CJQX_fmt{ #*18?FMT[bipw~
&-4;BIPW^elsz !(/6=DOVcpuz-B\v$<Tdy*5@Tanz!2>O_fmt{ #*18?FMT[bipw~(4@LZk{ "3EU_px!-?IUas $6BN\m
-:EQ]n}
%.7@IR[dmv!*3<ENW`ir{&/8AJS\enw ! * 3 < E N W ` i r { !!
!""commaaccentAbreveAmacronAogonekAEacuteCacuteCcaronCcircumflexCdotaccentDcaronDcroatEbreveEcaronEdotaccentEmacronEngEogonekGbreveGcircumflexGcommaaccentGdotaccentHbarHcircumflexIbreveIJImacronIogonekItildeJcircumflexKcommaaccentLacuteLcaronLcommaaccentLdotNacuteNcaronNcommaaccentObreveOhungarumlautOmacronOslashacuteRacuteRcaronRcommaaccentSacuteScedillaScircumflexScommaaccentTbarTcaronTcommaaccentUbreveUhungarumlautUmacronUogonekUringUtildeWacuteWcircumflexWdieresisWgraveYcircumflexYgraveZacuteZdotaccentIdotaccentabreveamacronaogonekaeacutecacuteccaronccircumflexcdotaccentdcarondcroatebreveecaronedotaccentemacronengeogonekgbrevegcircumflexgcommaaccentgdotaccenthbarhcircumflexibreveijimacroniogonekitildejcircumflexkcommaaccentlacutelcaronlcommaaccentldotnacutencaronncommaaccentobreveohungarumlautomacronoslashacuteracutercaronrcommaaccentsacutescedillascircumflexscommaaccenttbartcarontcommaaccentubreveuhungarumlautumacronuogonekuringutildewacutewcircumflexwdieresiswgraveycircumflexygravezacutezdotaccentkgreenlandiclongsnapostrophetonosdieresistonosAlphaBetaGammaDeltaEpsilonZetaEtaThetaIotaKappaLambdaMuNuXiOmicronPiRhoSigmaTauUpsilonPhiChiPsiOmegaAlphatonosEpsilontonosEtatonosIotatonosIotadieresisOmicrontonosUpsilontonosUpsilondieresisOmegatonosuni1FBBuni1F09uni1F0Duni1F0Buni1F0Funi1FB8uni1FBAuni1FBCuni1F89uni1F8Duni1F8Buni1F8Funi1F88uni1F8Cuni1F8Auni1F8Euni1F08uni1F0Cuni1F0Auni1F0Euni1FB9uni1FC9uni1F19uni1F1Duni1F1Buni1FC8uni1F18uni1F1Cuni1F1Auni1FCBuni1F29uni1F2Duni1F2Buni1F2Funi1FCAuni1FCCuni1F99uni1F9Duni1F9Buni1F9Funi1F98uni1F9Cuni1F9Auni1F9Euni1F28uni1F2Cuni1F2Auni1F2Euni1FDBuni1F39uni1F3Duni1F3Buni1F3Funi1FD8uni1FDAuni1F38uni1F3Cuni1F3Auni1F3Euni1FD9uni1FFBuni1F69uni1F6Duni1F6Buni1F6Funi1FFAuni1FFCuni1FA9uni1FADuni1FABuni1FAFuni1FA8uni1FACuni1FAAuni1FAEuni1F68uni1F6Cuni1F6Auni1F6Euni1FF9uni1F49uni1F4Duni1F4Buni1FF8uni1F48uni1F4Cuni1F4Auni1FECuni1FEBuni1F59uni1F5Duni1F5Buni1F5Funi1FE8uni1FEAuni1FE9alphabetagammadeltaepsilonzetaetathetaiotakappalambdanuxiomicronpirhosigmatauupsilonphichipsiomegaalphatonosepsilontonosetatonosiotatonosiotadieresisomicrontonosupsilontonosupsilondieresisomegatonosiotadieresistonosupsilondieresistonosuni03C2uni0374uni0375uni037Euni03D0uni03DAuni03DEuni03E0uni03F0uni1FBDuni1FBEuni1FC1uni1FCDuni1FCEuni1FCFuni1FDDuni1FDEuni1FDFuni1FEDuni1FEEuni1FFEuni1F00uni1F01uni1F02uni1F03uni1F04uni1F05uni1F06uni1F07uni1F10uni1F11uni1F12uni1F13uni1F14uni1F15uni1F20uni1F21uni1F22uni1F23uni1F24uni1F25uni1F26uni1F27uni1F30uni1F31uni1F32uni1F33uni1F34uni1F35uni1F36uni1F37uni1F40uni1F41uni1F42uni1F43uni1F44uni1F45uni1F50uni1F51uni1F52uni1F53uni1F54uni1F55uni1F56uni1F57uni1F60uni1F61uni1F62uni1F63uni1F64uni1F65uni1F66uni1F67uni1F70uni1F71uni1F72uni1F73uni1F74uni1F75uni1F76uni1F77uni1F78uni1F79uni1F7Auni1F7Buni1F7Cuni1F7Duni1F80uni1F81uni1F82uni1F83uni1F84uni1F85uni1F86uni1F87uni1F90uni1F91uni1F92uni1F93uni1F94uni1F95uni1F96uni1F97uni1FA0uni1FA1uni1FA2uni1FA3uni1FA4uni1FA5uni1FA6uni1FA7uni1FB0uni1FB1uni1FB2uni1FB3uni1FB6uni1FB7uni1FC2uni1FC3uni1FC4uni1FC6uni1FC7uni1FD0uni1FD1uni1FD2uni1FD3uni1FD6uni1FD7uni1FE0uni1FE1uni1FE2uni1FE3uni1FE4uni1FE5uni1FE6uni1FF2uni1FF3uni1FF4uni1FF6uni1FF7uni1FB4uni1FE7uniEFD5anoteleiauni03D1uni03D5uni03D6franclirapesetaEuroafii61289estimatedpartialdiffproductsummationuni2219radicalinfinityintegralapproxequalnotequallessequalgreaterequallozengeuni02C9uniEFEDuniEFEEuniEFF1uniEFF2uniEFF3uniEFF5uniEFF7AcuteCaronDieresisDieresisAcuteDieresisGraveGraveHungarumlautMacroncyrBrevecyrFlexdblGravecyrbrevecyrflexdblgravedieresisacutedieresisgraveuniF635uniF637uniF638uniF639uniF6DCuniF63AuniF63BuniF63CuniF63DuniF63EuniF63FuniF640uniF641uniF642uniF628uniF643uniF644uniF645uniF646uniF647uniF648uniF649uniF64AuniF64BuniF64CuniF64DuniF64EuniF64FuniF650uniF651uniF652uniF653uniF654uniF655uniF656uniF657uniF658uniF659uniF65AuniF65BuniF65CuniF65DuniF65EuniF65FuniF660uniF629uniF62AuniF62BuniF62CuniF62DuniF661uniF662uniF663uniF664uniF665uniF666uniF667uniF668uniF669uniF66AuniF66BuniF66CuniF62EuniF62FuniF630uniF631uniF632uniF66DuniF66EuniF66FuniF670uniF671uniF672uniF673uniF674uniF675uniF676uniF677uniF678uniF679uniF67AuniF67BuniF67CuniF67DuniF67EuniF67FuniF680uniF681uniF682uniF683uniF684uniF685uniF686uniF687uniF688uniF689uniF68AuniF68BuniF68CuniF68DuniF68EuniF68FuniF690uniF691uniF692uniF693uniF694uniF695uniF696uniF697uniF698uniF699uniF69AuniF69BuniF69CuniF69DuniF69EuniF69FuniF6A0uniF6A1uniF6A2uniF6A3uniF6A4uniF6A5uniF6A6uniF6A7uniF6A8uniF6A9uniF6AAuniF6ABuniF6ACuniF6ADuniF6AEuniF6AFuniF6B0uniF6B1uniF6B2uniF6B3uniF6B4uniF6B5uniF6B6uniF6B7uniF6B8uniF6B9uniF6BAuniF6BBuniF6BCuniF6BDuniF633c_hc_kc_tf_bf_f_bf_f_hf_f_kf_f_tf_hf_jf_f_jf_kf_ts_puniFB06T_hlongs_blongs_hlongs_ilongs_klongs_llongs_longsuniFB05longs_longs_ilongs_longs_la.ende.endm.endn.endr.endK.altR.altk.altcaron.altcommaaccent.altpeseta.altAlphaiotasub.altAlphaiotasubasper.altAlphaiotasubasperacute.altAlphaiotasubaspergrave.altAlphaiotasubaspertilde.altAlphaiotasublenis.altAlphaiotasublenisacute.altAlphaiotasublenisgrave.altAlphaiotasublenistilde.altEtaiotasub.altEtaiotasubasper.altEtaiotasubasperacute.altEtaiotasubaspergrave.altEtaiotasubaspertilde.altEtaiotasublenis.altEtaiotasublenisacute.altEtaiotasublenisgrave.altEtaiotasublenistilde.altOmegaiotasub.altOmegaiotasubasper.altOmegaiotasubasperacute.altOmegaiotasubaspergrave.altOmegaiotasubaspertilde.altOmegaiotasublenis.altOmegaiotasublenisacute.altOmegaiotasublenisgrave.altOmegaiotasublenistilde.altEuro.fittedcent.fittedcolonmonetary.fitteddollar.fittedflorin.fittedfranc.fittedlira.fittednumbersign.fittedsterling.fittedyen.fittedEuro.oldstylecolonmonetary.oldstyleestimated.oldstyleflorin.oldstylefranc.oldstylelira.oldstylenumbersign.oldstylesterling.oldstyleyen.oldstylefranc.taboldstylelira.taboldstyleorn.001orn.002orn.003orn.004orn.005orn.006orn.007orn.008orn.009orn.010orn.011orn.012orn.013orn.014orn.015orn.016orn.017orn.018orn.019orn.020orn.021orn.022orn.023A.swashB.swashC.swashD.swashE.swashF.swashG.swashH.swashI.swashJ.swashK.swashL.swashM.swashN.swashO.swashP.swashQ.swashR.swashS.swashT.swashU.swashV.swashW.swashX.swashY.swashZ.swashT_h.swashAacute.swashAbreve.swashAcircumflex.swashAdieresis.swashAgrave.swashAmacron.swashAogonek.swashAring.swashAtilde.swashCacute.swashCcaron.swashCcedilla.swashCcircumflex.swashCdotaccent.swashDcaron.swashDcroat.swashEacute.swashEbreve.swashEcaron.swashEcircumflex.swashEdieresis.swashEdotaccent.swashEgrave.swashEmacron.swashEng.swashEogonek.swashGbreve.swashGcircumflex.swashGcommaaccent.swashGdotaccent.swashHbar.swashHcircumflex.swashIJ.swashIacute.swashIbreve.swashIcircumflex.swashIdieresis.swashIdotaccent.swashIgrave.swashImacron.swashIogonek.swashItilde.swashJcircumflex.swashKcommaaccent.swashLacute.swashLcaron.swashLcommaaccent.swashLdot.swashNacute.swashNcaron.swashNcommaaccent.swashNtilde.swashOacute.swashObreve.swashOcircumflex.swashOdieresis.swashOgrave.swashOhungarumlaut.swashOmacron.swashOslash.swashOslashacute.swashOtilde.swashRacute.swashRcaron.swashRcommaaccent.swashSacute.swashScaron.swashScedilla.swashScircumflex.swashScommaaccent.swashTbar.swashTcaron.swashTcommaaccent.swashT_h.caronswashT_h.commaaccentswashUacute.swashUbreve.swashUcircumflex.swashUdieresis.swashUgrave.swashUhungarumlaut.swashUmacron.swashUogonek.swashUring.swashUtilde.swashWacute.swashWcircumflex.swashWdieresis.swashWgrave.swashYacute.swashYcircumflex.swashYdieresis.swashYgrave.swashZacute.swashZcaron.swashZdotaccent.swashafii10056T_h.caronT_h.commaaccentafii10048afii10074afii10075afii10082afii10192afii10062afii10194afii10193afii10102afii10071afii10041afii10076afii10085afii10103afii10051afii10039afii10037afii10079afii10061afii10059afii10047afii10067afii10049afii10148afii10033afii10094afii10080afii10022afii10145afii10063afii10027afii10070afii10054afii10109afii10036afii10065afii10055afii10068afii10086afii10064afii10096afii10050afii10146afii10077afii10097afii10069afii10107afii10101afii10043afii10078afii10024afii10073afii10089afii10092afii10147afii10087afii10081afii10029afii10083afii10026afii10019afii10032afii10046afii10072afii10021afii10030afii10098afii10038afii10017afii10040afii10042afii10105afii10052afii10057afii10025afii10034afii10053afii10832afii10058afii10018afii10044afii10110afii10020afii10095Rholenisafii10104afii10106afii10090afii10091afii10060afii10028afii10045afii10099afii10066afii10084afii10031afii10196afii10035afii10088afii10093Eth.swashafii10100uni0394afii10023afii10195uni2215uni021Aafii10108uni03BCuni00ADuni00A0uni03A9uni021Bafii10846afii61352afii10831Copyright 2000 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved. U.S. Patents Des. 338,907 and 371,799.Minion is either a registered trademark or a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated in the United States and/or other countries.Minion Pro ItalicMinion Proq N s ^mTw6zgjTRC @ q
C
d
m
r$7
,
Q
c
!*D )d Gcw~!;FJ3%3@FP8ir3y1S_ju(/6:n . 9 C v !!/!5!`!h!!!!!"""@"g"t"|""""###W#\#h#n#v######$$ $&$,$3$:$K$U$r$$$$$$$$$% %%%5%D%]%h%o%v%%%%%%%%%%%& &&,&9&C&J&P&U&j&&&&&&&&&&&''''#'(':'L'Q'\'a'g'x'''''''''(((%(/(7(>(E(L([(j(w(~((((((((((((((())))!).)9)D)K)R)Y)`)f)k)o)t))))))))))))))**
****%*0*;*F*Q*\*g*r*}*****-
oFl\8Mgk^?ŜeQ[a`FpUI߹|{{|VsrocghpzvL##4/Jcݹ+!MWagpu
|;;.|;9hꖧovgtfstqon@Sm|}ĬD⋄DQnJs8*Tlb~wg8`F(;@§ŰY9kde:S!VtVl-ܲq
m
ބ}A98}@=
^98ԏڒ,`fhMhx{r/S#Qݟ9ʞJ+^VT\]xZ]Rmh
dn$d_JoDO(q
zm
ӇbjVy-}EVeF4)AKڑף
ڄ|>[tA_d}ʟɩ藿ΎwC{LZnXH;slz`Z?; :\o"T÷ķT`ź_j{xR{YvPwUBy
|s^`_ZNu[XUoaN{;iV`VsjaK]<_IZF"v,
b|bw`tgigxumjbisˎA{lW_ïknruxutnivry?y>x? rxǼiwi4wxηŻ6xyppvTyJyQ,|;7
^1؟svmdؓd
upՆ]oXy.]#m
vu|YWx.^h~_tWpy^Fy_pp͆SVQL
owÐˑ_Dm
{qtg`O_Rxo|TpgC]cwxz8REpzD掚˴k[uqlchkmXfjevrkpocjfq~z~|zhfsPfnwr
Wym{qhlb\2\)FWy:y1er}yo;ڕԑZhĚڰW-Änj~sypkWkuo_8lewߢۂ|ogYQZktY00=ZH<4 Eu{tzy{|wB/`J
aoAh{1~Ug^YoG=E)?XEݻd9N9&)^:<>