The future of self-assessment in classroom practice: Reframing self-assessment as a core competency

ResearchSpace/Manakin Repository

Show simple item record Brown, Gavin en Harris, LR en 2014-10-21T03:07:33Z en 2014 en
dc.identifier.citation Frontline Learning Research, 2014, 2 (1), pp. 22 - 30 en
dc.identifier.issn 2295-3159 en
dc.identifier.uri en
dc.description.abstract Formative assessment policies argue that student self-assessment of work products and processes is useful for raising academic performance. This view draws on self-regulation of learning theories about setting targets and evaluating progress against criteria as a basis for meta-cognitively informed improvement of learning outcomes. However, the reliability of assessment is necessary for the validity of assessment interpretations. Research into psychological processes underlying the human ability to self-evaluate work raises serious doubts about the quality of students’ judgments. It has been shown that novices (i.e., students) tend to lack sufficient knowledge by which to evaluate their own work appropriately and, when possessing that knowledge, they are likely not to make use of it. Additionally, psychological safety factors indicate that self-assessment can be compromised by interpersonal relations present in classroom environments. Furthermore, since progress in many educational domains is relatively ill-defined, it is difficult for learners, let alone instructors, to validly evaluate progress or status. A recent review of studies in elementary and secondary schooling (K-12) found that the correlation between self-ratings and teacher ratings, between self-estimates of performance and actual test scores, and between student and teacher rubric-based judgments tended to be positive, ranging from weak to moderate (i.e., values ranging from r ≈ .20 to .80), with few studies reporting correlations r > .60. However, these values were not consistent across student experience and academic proficiency, with much less accuracy seen with younger and less proficient students. This paper argues that, instead of treating student self-assessment as an assessment method, a more pedagogical approach is needed that treats self-assessment as an important student competence or skill. As such self-evaluation needs a developmentally appropriate curriculum that is developed incrementally over time through consistent, scaffolded training and practice. Hence, to improve student skills in self-assessment, research must examine how the underlying skills required for self-assessment map onto student cognitive capabilities and the task characteristics of the work students are likely to encounter as they progress through schooling. This progression (like those developed for other key competencies like literacy, numeracy, and critical thinking) would help teachers consistently implement developmentally appropriate versions of self-assessment, giving students opportunities to develop these life-long skills. en
dc.relation.ispartofseries Frontline Learning Research en
dc.rights Items in ResearchSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated. Previously published items are made available in accordance with the copyright policy of the publisher. Details obtained from en
dc.rights.uri en
dc.rights.uri en
dc.title The future of self-assessment in classroom practice: Reframing self-assessment as a core competency en
dc.type Journal Article en
dc.identifier.doi 10.14786/flr.v2i1.24 en
pubs.issue 1 en
pubs.begin-page 22 en
pubs.volume 2 en
dc.description.version VoR - Version of Record en
pubs.end-page 30 en
pubs.publication-status Published en
dc.rights.accessrights en
pubs.subtype Article en
pubs.elements-id 430748 en Education and Social Work en Learning Development and Professional Practice en
pubs.record-created-at-source-date 2014-03-22 en

Full text options

Find Full text

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as


Search ResearchSpace

Advanced Search