dc.contributor.author |
Wilkinson, Timothy |
en |
dc.date.accessioned |
2018-10-11T20:55:32Z |
en |
dc.date.issued |
2016-11-14 |
en |
dc.identifier.issn |
1754-9973 |
en |
dc.identifier.uri |
http://hdl.handle.net/2292/40982 |
en |
dc.description.abstract |
It is generally wrong to manipulate. One leading reason is because manipulation interferes with autonomy, in particular the component of autonomy called ‘independence’, that is, freedom from intentional control by others. Manipulative health promotion would therefore seem wrong. However, manipulative techniques could be used to counter-manipulation, for example, playing on male fears of impotence to counter ‘smoking is sexy’ advertisements. What difference does it make to the ethics of manipulation when it is counter-manipulation? This article distinguishes two powerful defences of counter-manipulative health promotion: that the counter-manipulation would prevent manipulation occurring, leaving people unmanipulated; and that the counter-manipulation would make people healthier without being any more manipulated than they would otherwise be. The article explains how counter-manipulation might work and the limits to its scope. The upshot is that counter-manipulative health promotion could respect the independence people are owed in virtue of their autonomy. However, autonomy is not the only consideration, and the article discusses further potential problems. Counter-manipulative health promotion might be misapplied, it might undermine trust, it might infringe on some norms for role behaviour and it might encourage a regrettable social practice. These objections are likely to be decisive against the counter-manipulation in some but not all cases. |
en |
dc.publisher |
Oxford University Press |
en |
dc.relation.ispartofseries |
Public Health Ethics |
en |
dc.rights |
Items in ResearchSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated. Previously published items are made available in accordance with the copyright policy of the publisher. |
en |
dc.rights.uri |
https://researchspace.auckland.ac.nz/docs/uoa-docs/rights.htm |
en |
dc.title |
Counter-Manipulation and Health Promotion |
en |
dc.type |
Journal Article |
en |
dc.identifier.doi |
10.1093/phe/phw044 |
en |
dc.rights.holder |
Copyright: The author |
en |
pubs.publication-status |
Published online |
en |
dc.rights.accessrights |
http://purl.org/eprint/accessRights/RestrictedAccess |
en |
pubs.subtype |
Article |
en |
pubs.elements-id |
609615 |
en |
pubs.org-id |
Arts |
en |
pubs.org-id |
Social Sciences |
en |
pubs.org-id |
Politics & International Relations |
en |
dc.identifier.eissn |
1754-9981 |
en |
pubs.record-created-at-source-date |
2017-05-18 |
en |
pubs.online-publication-date |
2016 |
en |